Capstone Reflective Journal
Criteria
Excellent
Good
Developing
Not Acceptable
Criterion Score
Title Slide: Title of project, your name, EBP Proposal site
1 point
All three items clearly stated.
0.66 points
Two items included.
0.33 points
Only one item present.
0 points
All items missing / 1
Significance of the problem and PICO(T) Question
1 point
Clear and complete on slide content.
0.66 points
Discussion with some detail lacking on slide content.
0.33 points
Unclear from the slide content.
0 points
Not addressed or discussed.
/ 1
Evidence Review
1 point
Clear and complete on slide content.
0.66 points
Discussion with some detail lacking on slide content.
0.33 points
Unclear from the slide content.
0 points
Not addressed or discussed.
/ 1
Plan for Implementation
1 point
Clear and complete on slide content.
0.66 points
Discussion with some detail lacking on slide content.
0.33 points
Unclear from the slide content.
0 points
Not addressed or discussed.
/ 1
Plan for Evaluation
1 point
Clear and complete on slide content.
0.66 points
Discussion with some detail lacking on slide content.
0.33 points
Unclear from the slide content.
0 points
Not addressed or discussed.
/ 1
Conclusion and Recommendations
1 point
Clear and complete on slide content.
0.66 points
Discussion with some detail lacking on slide content.
0.33 points
Unclear from the slide content.
0 points
Not addressed or discussed.
/ 1
References
1 point
All references included and in proper APA format
0.66 points
All references included with minimal APA error.
0.33 points
Incomplete references or major APA errors.
0 points
No attempt to include references or use APA.
/ 1
PowerPoint Layout and Slides
3 points
Slide layout is visually appealing. Pictures or graphics do not distract reader from the content. Slides are not excessively wordy. No grammar or spelling issues.
2 points
Slide layout is visually appealing but pictures or graphics may distract reader slightly. Slides may be wordier than recommended. Minor grammar or spelling issues that do not distract the reader.
1 point
One of the following: Slide layout is not visually appealing. Pictures or graphics distract reader. Slides crowded with words. Grammar or spelling issues that distract the reader.
0 points
More than one of the following: Slide layout is not visually appealing. Pictures or graphics distract reader. Slides crowded with words. Grammar or spelling issues that distract the reader.
/ 3