PICOT QUESTION FORMATION
|
PICOT Question Rubric There should be no duplication of topics within the class |
|||||
|
|
Excellent 10 |
Good 7 – 9 |
Fair 4 – 6 |
Poor 0 – 3 |
Score |
|
Problem Identification |
Problem is identified and stated clearly. |
Problem is identified, but not stated clearly. |
|
Problem is not identified. |
|
|
Relevance of Problem to Clinical Practice and/or Nursing Profession
|
Background and significance of problem to nursing is clear, concise, and supported by adequate and current evidence. |
Background and significance of problem to nursing is clear and concise. Some evidence is included to support the need to address the chosen problem OR evidence included is not current. |
Background and significance of problem to nursing is unclear. No evidence is included to support the need to address the chosen problem. |
Background and significance of the problem are not explained. No evidence is included to support the need to address this chosen problem. |
|
|
PICO(T) Components |
All PICO(T) components are clearly identified.
|
Most elements PICO(T) components are clearly identified. |
Some PICO(T) components are clearly identified. |
PICO(T) components are unclear leaving reader confused. |
|
|
PICO(T) Question |
PICOT question is concise and supported by background and significance of clinical problem to nursing. No errors in grammar and usage are noted. |
PICOT question is supported by background and significance of clinical problem to nursing. Some errors in grammar and usage are noted. |
Unclear how PICOT question is supported by background and significance of clinical problem to nursing. |
PICOT muddled, elements missing or poorly narrowed. |
|
|
Search Terms & Databases & Strategies
|
Identified search terms are logical and related to the question. Search strategies and selected databases are appropriate for the research question. |
Search terms are related to the question, though some may be missing. Search strategies and selected databases are appropriate for the research question. |
Search terms are related to the question, though some may be incorrect or missing. Search strategies and selected databases are not appropriate for the research question. |
Search terms are not related to the question. Search strategies and selected databases are not appropriate for the research question. |
|
|
Total Score for PICOT Question |
/50
|