Writing thesis

QRedSox
CURNUTTAmLit2DiscussionQuestionsRubric1-1.docx

American Lit 2 Discussion Questions Rubric

18-20 POINTS

17-14 POINTS

10-14 POINTS

1. Formats the thesis statement according to the following formula: In (date, genre text), (author) (action verb, eg dramatizes, illustrates, etc) the function of (the tool or technique in the prompt) in order to (accomplish a purpose/make a point).

Example (not from our syllabus): In his 1851 novel The Scarlet Letter, Nathaniel Hawthorne dramatizes the power of literary ambiguity over literal interpretations of language by depicting multiple interpretations of the letter A that Hester Prynne is forced to wear to argue that America’s Puritan ancestors lacked imagination.

2. Includes at least 3 paragraphs, possibly 5, with a clear introduction and conclusion.

3. Written in 3rd person only—avoids “I,” “we,” and “you”

4. Avoids abstract verbs like “is” that connote presence instead of action verbs like “dramatizes,” illustrates, calls attention to, etc. to give the thesis some action and movement

5. Addresses works on the syllabus for this lesson

6. Correctly uses Copilot ( https://copilot.microsoft.com/chats/ftDtWsqh7gZ9Lxh2ogvKJ Links to an external site. ) to create a potential OUTLINE (not a draft) that is then expanded into a full-length post. Please upload your outline in an MSWord file with each DQ. This requirement is to control how students use AI tools.

7. Correctly formats titles: quotation marks for short stories ("Life in the Iron Mills"), italics for full-length works ( The Waste Land). Please follow the formatting in the lesson or check Wikipedia for corroboration on proper title formatting for each work. THIS IS THE EASIEST THING YOU CAN LEARN THIS TERM, SO LET'S KNOCK IT OUT in LESSON 1.

8. Includes a supporting quote from the primary source that is placed in sentence 5 of the paragraph as textual evidence of the point made.

9. Topic sentences in the body paragraph state the purpose or function of the example to be analyzed.

10. Conclusion avoids cliched language such as “In conclusion” in favor of livelier transitions like “In the end” or “Ultimately”

Fails to include 3 or more of the requirements above

Fails to incorporate instructor suggestions from previous weekend’s posts

Includes references to works not on the syllabus

Includes secondary sources that students have not likely read

LESS THAN 10

Shows telltale evidence that a draft (not an outline) was generated by AI. These traits include (but are not limited to) the following:

1. Is divided into subsections with titles instead of being one cohesive post

2. Uses APA style (eg., Davis, 1861, pg. X) instead of MLA style (just page number)

3. Includes a Works Cited formatted in APA style; no bibliography is required for our posts

4. Language feels stilted and mechanical (uses “In conclusion,” for example)

5. Fails to address the prompt by lacking a clear thesis