CRJ325 WEEK 7 DQ
Week 7 Discussion
Top of Form
Total views: 35 (Your views: 1)
"Lineups and Other Means of Pretrial Identification" Please respond to the following:
· Read the article, “The Problem with Eyewitness Testimony Commentary on a talk by George Fisher and Barbara Tversky."
· Next, explain three major issues that you can identify as it relates to lineups and other means of pretrial identification.
· Lastly, identify and describe three situations in which you feel that Miranda warnings are not required as it relates to arrest, custody, and interrogation.
· Reply to the post of at least one of your classmates (BELOW) with a meaningful reply that compares or contrasts the classmate's post to yours or adds further insight into the topic. A meaningful Reply will typically contain at least 100 words.
Lisa Arrington
RE: Week 7 Discussion Attachment
Hello Professor and Classmates. After reading the article, the three major issues I got out of eyewitness identification in lineups and other means are, a persons memory could be jarred by things that did not happen, based on some events that may have been too hard for them to see, like maybe a car accident, shooting, etc. Then, a persons memory could be falsely interrupted by what others may have said or during questioning by investigators, based on their questions. And then in lineups a person could mistake a person who did not commit a crime with the person who actually did, based on certain features that they may have in common. The Miranda warning does not apply to me in situations where a suspect is caught for shoplifting, and they are detained by security, it does not apply because they security officers are not the police. And if a cop stops a person and questions them, before they are arrested, then Miranda does not apply because they are not under arrest and no handcuffs were put on them. And Lastly, if the questions are only asking a persons name, their address, or date of birth, then Miranda warning does not apply, because these questions are not in a manner that would be considered an interrogation. In other words, in order for Miranda to apply, the questions must be in a manner that the answers they give may incriminate them in one way or another.
Bottom of Form
Bottom of Form
PUBLISHED
9e0c20ee-3de9-4
false