Critique
• Give a brief explanation for each of your award winners. (~150 words)
o Include the names of the winners you choose.
o In your analysis, discuss the kinds of value you think were relevant to winning the award.
o Discuss whether the extent to which the relevant values are determined by objective features of the art or mind-dependent features.
o If there were multiple kinds of value in play, discuss how you balanced or weighed each kind of value.
o Weave a discussion of at least one of the readings into your analysis.
• Go meta and briefly discuss what makes a good/valuable critique. (~150 words)
o What’s the value in your critique?
• You will list your winners (and brief explanations for why) as the first part of your Critique.
• Here are the awards categories:
o Best Overall Work of Art
o Best Philosophical Content/Connection
o Most Creative Work of Art
o Most Persuasive Work of Art
o Most Socially Conscious Art