CounterargumentTemplate.docx
Professor Siegel
Organizing a Counterargument
Counterarguing is a high risk, high reward strategy in argumentation. A strong counterargument can successfully demonstrate why an alternative is wrong, however, a weak one can leave your argument open to attack. Remember that you can’t just burn down the alternative; you also have to salt the earth so that nothing ever grows there again.
|
Address the opposition/alternative
|
|
· This is your topic sentence
· Clearly express the subject and content of the paragraph
· Make sure key terms (and people) are defined
|
Some phrases/transitions to consider:
· According to…, Popular opinion/belief states that..., While many people/experts agree/argue…
|
|
|
|
Segue/transition into stating that this is wrong and lead into why
|
|
· Express that the argument is incomplete, weak, or illogical
· Don’t just summarize their argument; respond to it
|
Some phrases/transitions to consider:
· However, nonetheless, despite this, on the contrary…
|
|
|
|
Provide specific examples to demonstrate
|
|
· Identify specific examples from their side, then use evidence from your side and state why they are wrong or fallacious
· Use your argumentation strategies to demonstrate why they are wrong: Aristotelian appeals, prognostication, agitate-and-solve, etc…
|
Some phrases/transitions to consider:
· Rather, yet, instead, but, nevertheless, still, regardless…
|
|
|
|
Close by stating your position and why it is stronger
|
|
· This is your concluding sentence
· Summarize and link back to the thesis/your position
|
Some phrases/transitions to consider:
· Therefore, so, in conclusion, to sum up…
|
|
|