Business
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Getting Started
Patterns of Entrepreneurship Management 5th Edition, Chapter 3
Designing Business Models Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Presentation Outline
• Definition of Business Models
• Tools for Development
• Examples
• Licensing and Franchising
• Outsourcing
• Models Based on Networks
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Business Model Definitions
• With the business environment evolving in such a
dynamic and rapid way, it is no longer sufficient for a
company to build a company solely around a new
product or service idea.
• A business model is a description of how your
company intends to create value in the marketplace. It
includes that unique combination of products,
services, image and distribution that your business
carries forward. It also includes the underlying
organization of people, and the operational
infrastructure that they use to accomplish their work.
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Business Models
More Simply:
“A business model is the way a company
applies knowledge to capture value.”
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Business Model Components
Requires blending of multiple business aspects:
• Manufacturing
• Finance
• Marketing
• Information
• Suppliers and Customers
• Product and Service development
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
•A Business Model states how a company creates VALUE in the
market
•A Business Model is more than just strategy – it is the fundamental
architecture of a business
• Good Business Models are:
- SCALABLE
- Create BARRIERS TO FOLLOWSHIP
- Align the Interests of ALL STAKEHOLDERS
- Provide VALUE to ALL STAKEHOLDERS
- Use NETWORK effects
- Are CAPITAL efficient
- Provide sustainable high GROSS MARGINS
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Attributes of a Good Business Model
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Business Model Canvas (Osterwalder Model)
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
• We are part of a complex supply chain. Who are our
key partners? Why do we need them and vice versa?
• What is unique about what we can do better than
others? What are our key activities? How do we
contribute to the value proposition?
• What are the needs for each subgroup of customers?
What value are they seeking?
• What key resources do we need to perform our
activities—human, intellectual, financial, and
physical?
Canvas Components -1
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Canvas Components -2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
• Who are our customers, and how do we
contribute to the value proposition?
• How do we relate to these selected
customers?
• How do we segment these customers,
and which are the most valuable to us?
• How do we get to these customers?
• Where are the major costs? For our
resources? For our activities?
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Minimum Viable Product
• Minimum Viable Product (MVP) is the
product with the highest return on investment
versus risk.
• MVP’s help start-up companies test
customers’ reactions early and use the results
to guide product development
• MVP’s reduce the need for funding
• MVP’s reduce risk in product development
and improvements
• MVP’s should be a component of a business
model Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Example - Disrupting the Supply Chain
• Used pioneering “Direct Model” in this industry that allows them to provide a customized product, superior technology, and superior service, for a low-cost.
• Model based on: One-to-one customer contact, Accountability, Made-to-Order, and Non- Unique Products (modularity)
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Greif
Bros.
IBC
Vendor
Management/
Software/Models
GPS
(Drum
Cleaners)
Delta Chemical
Services
(Environmental
Analyses)
Palex
(Pallet and
Drum
Refurbishers)
Greif becomes Center of Synergistic Supplier Network
Shifts from a Product Supplier to a Problem Solver
New
Truckers
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Example – Re-structuring
the Supply Chain
Example – Netflix Use of Data-Mining
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Example – Netflix, (contd.) Early-mover Advantage and Accumulation of Customer
Data Provides Sustainable Business Model
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Example - DBI Inc. Using Accumulated Data
to Build Customer “Lock-in”
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
On-Off Road/Rail Truck with Robotic “Spot” Sprayers, GPS
Mapping of Vegetation Types Allows Continuous Efficiency
Improvements. Database Maps Create Customer Lock-in.
Example - DBI Inc. Unique Vehicle + Database of Vegetation
Allows Fast Service – Important for Railroads.
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Licensing and Franchising
• Licensing and Franchising are two valuable
components of a business model
• Both are agreements between an issuer—a
licensor or franchisor—and a receiver—a
licensee or franchisee.
• These contracts grant the receivers certain
rights to access certain “intellectual properties”
such as patents, trademarks, trade secrets, and
copyrights
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2012 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
License Agreements
License agreements allow a licensee to
use intellectual property under certain
conditions as spelled out in the
agreement.
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
License Agreements: Key Issues
1. Licensee and Licensor are identified together
on the basis of their reasons for entering into
an agreement
2. The licensed Intellectual Property (IP) is
precisely defined
3. The granted rights to the IP are carefully
defined
4. The “territory” allowed for practice of the
rights is defined
5. The level of exclusivity is defined
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
License Agreements: Key Issues
6. In exchange for gaining certain rights, the
licensee pays fees to the licensor. These
usually include up-front fees, running
royalties, or periodic payments
7. Other items considered: term of the
agreement, confidentiality, payment
scheduling, need for audit, treatment of
breaches of contract, warranties, liabilities,
indemnifications, and other general legal
requirements
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Example: James Dyson Licensed Asian Rights to “Bootstrap” his Company. He Later Bought Them Back.
Hoover Turned Down his Licensing Offer!
Picture Copyright Dyson Inc.
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Example-Ultrafast’s Business Model with Multiple Licenses to Complementary Tool Companies Solving
both Marketing and Funding Problems
Ultrafast Inc. Technology Development
Applications Engineering
Licensing Office
Assembly Tool
Companies
After Market Tool
Companies
Fastener Makers
Car Assembly
Plants
Segmented Licenses
Coating
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Franchise Agreements
A franchise is a legal and commercial
relationship between the owner
(franchisor) of a trademark, service
mark, trade name, or advertising symbol
and an individual or group (franchisee)
wishing to use that identification in a
business.
Example:
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Franchise Agreements: Key Issues
1. Franchisee and franchisor are defined
together for the reason they are entering into
the agreement
2. The business of the franchise is stated, and
the deliverables that the franchisor must
provide to the franchisee are specified
3. The franchisor my offer to fund part of the
start-up costs
4. The commitments of the franchisee are
defined
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Franchise Agreements: Key Issues
5. In exchange for entering into the agreement
and receiving support from the franchisor,
the franchisee pays fees to the franchisor
6. Items stating under what terms a franchisee
can sell its business
7. Other terms: term of agreement, conditions
for renewal, confidentiality, payment
scheduling, need for audit, treatment of
breaches of contract, warranties, liabilities,
indemnifications, other legal requirements
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Example - Chemstation’s Unique Business Model Built on Regional Franchises
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Outsourcing
Has become a viable option due to the following:
• To realize cost efficiencies/economies of scale
• To realize core competencies
• To leave specialized tasks to the specialists
• To free up essential resources from non-core
functions
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Outsourcing: The Choice
Checklist for whether you should outsource:
• Is the activity central to the company’s
success?
• Can the outsourcing lead to a loss of
intellectual property rights or a leakage of
valuable trade secrets to competitors of their
suppliers?
• Is the task routine and wasteful of your staff’s
time?
• Is this a one-off or periodic need?
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Outsourcing: The Choice
Checklist (continued):
• Is it less expensive to have an outsider do it rather than in-house?
• Alternatively, will the task cost less in-house BUT use resources that are more valuable elsewhere?
• Is the skill so specialized that it’s impractical to have a full-time employee provide the best input?
If none of these questions elicit concern, you should consider outsourcing the task.
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Outsourcing: The Choice
Tips for finding an external resource:
• Ask around for recommendations
• Choose a company that understands your
needs and can meet them
• Outsourcing implies a loss of direct control, so
clearly communicate the performance
standards
• Meet regularly
• Have a backup plan
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Threadless.com – customers design products for free, sales generated
prior to manufacture.
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Social Networks in Business Models
Social Networks in Business Models. Example - Threadless
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
P&G’s Social Network for Moms with Kids
provides new ideas and viral marketing.
Social Networks in Business Models. Example - Vocalpoint
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Idea and Initial Market Research undertaken via Vocalpoint
Social Networks in Business Models.
P&G Launches eStore to sell Tide direct to
Customers
Chapter 3
Business Models
Licensing & Franchising
Outsourcing
Network Models
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren