Business
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Getting Started
Patterns of Entrepreneurship Management 5th Edition, Chapter 2
The Art of Innovation -Developing
Ideas and Business Opportunities
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. arren
Presentation Outline
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2 • Why Innovate?
– Macro-economic Trends
– Types of Innovation
– Framework
– Frameworks for Innovation
• Making an Idea an Opportunity
• Evaluating the Opportunity
– Questions
– Opportunity Costs
– Framework
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Why Innovate?
• The Growth of the Internet
• Shift to a Service Economy
• Reduction of International Trade Barriers
• International Free-Flows of Capital
• Rapid Technological Obsolescence
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Types of Innovation
• The S-Curve of Innovation
• Derivative vs. Radical
• Disruptive Innovation
- Candles to Incandescent Lighting
• Incremental Innovation
- Evolution of Designer Candles
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Derivative Innovation gives
Incremental Improvements
Time
Performance
The S-Curves with Incremental Innovation
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Derivative Innovation
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
S-Curves for a Disruptive Innovation
Disruptive Innovation
Leads to Radical Changes
Time
Performance
Time to adopt radical innovation –
before performance advantages.
Disruptive Innovation
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Time
Candles
Incandescent Lamps
Discharge Lamps
LED’s P
e rf
o rm
a n c e
Waves of Disruption in Lighting
New Disruptive Technologies Changed the
Lighting Industry Many Times – What’s Next?
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Models for Innovation
• Analogs
- Leafbusters
• Intersection of Technology Trends
- Netflix and Streaming Video
• “Points of Pain”
- SmartPak
• Analysis of Existing Businesses
- SuperFast Pizza
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Where Ideas for Opportunities Originate
Improving
Existing
Technology,
Product, or
Service
15%
Vision of
Opportunity
11%
Present Work
Environment
47%
Secondary
Sources:
Brainstorming,
Trade
Publications,
Commerce
Business Only,
Idea Brokers,
Venture Capital
Firms,
Technology
Transfer
Agencies
27%
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Converting an Idea into an Opportunity
What is an Opportunity?
• Identifying which business ideas have
real commercial potential is one of the
most difficult challenges that an
entrepreneur will face.
Seize the Opportunity
• Know what factors create opportunity out
of an initial idea.
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
The Five Phases to Success
•Recognize the Opportunity and ACT
•Investigate the Need
•Develop the Plan
•Determine the Resources Needed
•Manage the Business
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating
the Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Questions to Evaluate the Business Opportunity
• What indicators suggest the idea may be the
basis of a valuable and viable opportunity?
• What are the conditions that enable the
opportunity to be successful?
• How might the future of the initial product
or service change over time?
• How long (in terms of time) is the window
of opportunity?
• How big is the opportunity?
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Evaluating the Opportunity
Does the Opportunity……
Fill a need that customers will value?
Show evidence of customer acceptance?
Show that a substantial market exists now?
Indicate that your solution is much better than the competition?
Show a significant upside potential?
Can be achieved with reasonable costs?
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Frameworks for Evaluating an Opportunity - 1
Market Issues:
Criterion Stronger Opportunity Weaker Opportunity
Need Identified Unclear
Customers Reachable; receptive Unreachable or loyalties
established
Payback to user/customer Less than one year Three years or more
Product life cycle Long; recover investment Short; recover investment
Industry structure Competition or emerging Aggressively competitive
Potential market size $100 million sales Less than $10 million sales
Market growth rate Growing at 30% to 50% Contracting less than 10%
Gross margins 30% to 50% Less than 20%; volatile
Market share attainable (year 5) 20% or more Less than 5%
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Frameworks for Evaluating an Opportunity – 2
Financial and Harvest Issues:
Criterion Stronger Opportunity Weaker Opportunity
Profits after tax 10% to 15% or more; durable Less than 5%; fragile
Time to:
Break-even
Positive cash flow
ROI potential
Under 2 years
Under 2 years
25% or more per year
More than 3 years
More than 3 years
Less than 15-20% per year
Value
Capital requirements
High strategic value
Low to moderate; fundable
Low strategic value
Very high; unfundable
Exit mechanism Present or envisioned harvest
options
Undefined; illiquid
investment
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Frameworks for Evaluating an Opportunity - 3
Competitive Advantage Issues:
Criterion Stronger Opportunity Weaker Opportunity
Fixed and Variable Costs
Production, marketing
distribution
Lowest
Highest
Degree of Control
Prices, channels of
resources/distribution
Moderate to strong
Weak
Barriers to Entry
Proprietary protection
Response/lead time
Yes
6 months to one year
None
None
Legal contractual advantage Proprietary of exclusivity None
Sources of differentiation Numerous Few or none
Competitors mindset and
strategies
Live and let live; not self
destructive
Defensive and strongly
reactive
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2
Copyright 2015 Jack M. Kaplan & Anthony C. Warren
Frameworks for Evaluating an Opportunity - 4
Management Team and Risk Issues:
Criterion Stronger Opportunity Weaker Opportunity
Management team Existing, strong, proven
performance
Weak, inexperienced,
lacking key skills
Contacts and networks Well-developed; high
quality; accessible
Crude; limited; inaccessible
Risk Low High
Fatal Flaws None One or more
Idea to
Opportunity
Evaluating the
Opportunity
Why Innovate
Chapter 2