Discussion 8

Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility and Law

Chapter 5 !"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Chapter Overview

! "#$%&'()*%&+*,'%-'*()+.,/ ! 0)*'1*-+2+(+%2'%-'34,+2*,,'*()+.,'#21',(#5*)%61*&,/ ! 0)*'.)#66*27*,'#21',(&#(*7+.'#18#2(#7*,'%-'8#64*, 9#2#7*9*2(/ ! :421#9*2(#6,'%-'.%&;%&#(*',%.+#6'&*,;%2,+3+6+(</

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

What is Ethics?

! "%&#6,' ! "#$#%&''()&**#+,#-).,&$-&%-.)/0)%1"2,)&$-)3%/$")1$)& "14#$)./*1#,()/%)*/556$1,( ! 5&()7#)7&.#-)/$),2#)'&38)/$#9.)%#'1"1/$8)/$#9.)+#%./$&') 7#'1#0).(.,#5.8)/%)./5#)*/571$&,1/$)/0)&''),2%##:

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

What is Ethics?

! =()+.,' ! ,2#).#,)/0)5/%&')+%1$*1+'#.)/%)*/%#)4&'6#.)0/%)-#*1-1$") 7#,3##$)%1"2,)&$-)3%/$" ! 2&41$")&)*/$.*1/6.).(.,#5)1$)+'&*#)0/%)./'41$")5/%&') -1'#55&.:

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Principles-Based Approaches

! >*6+7+%2 ! ;,21*&')-#*1.1/$.),2&,)&%#)5&-#)&**/%-1$"),/)&).#,)/0) #.,&7'1.2#-)+%1$*1+'#.)/%).,&$-&%-.).6*2)&.)%#'1"1/6.),#$#,.) /%)*/-#.

! ?+&(4* ! #4&'6&,#.)*/$-6*,)7&.#-)/$)32#,2#%)1,)+%/5/,#. "//-)5/%&')*2&%&*,#%:

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Principles-Based Approaches

! "#$%&#'()#* ! "#$%&'&"#()'*+%,$-*.#,.*#/-,0'*#,1(*+().,$0*$0#()(0.*-&),%* )$2#.'*,03*3/.$('*.#,.*'")$02*4)&-*.#($)*,5$%$.6*.&*)(,'&0*,03* +#&&'(*4)((%6*7#,.*.#(6*3&*7$.#*.#($)*%$1(

! +#$,-.&/0#'(123,&#$/4, ! &0(*'#&/%3*,+.*-&),%%6*5(+,/'(*$.*$'*.#(*)$2#.*.#$02*.&*3&8*7$.#&/.* ,06*/%.()$&)*-&.$1( ! $0#()(0.*0&.$&0*.#,.*#/-,0'*'#&/%3*,+.*4)&-*,*'(0'(*&4*3/.6*.&* #/-,0*3$20$.69*

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Consequences-Based Approach

! @%2,*A4*2.*,BC#,*1'D;;&%#.) ! #5+2&.1<#.),2&,),2#)#,21*&')*/6%.#)/0)&*,1/$)1.),2#)/$#),2&,) +%/41-#.),2#)"%#&,#.,)"//-)=2&++1$#..>)0/%),2#)"%#&,#.,) $657#%)/0)+#/+'#)&$-)2&.),2#)'#&.,)2&%506')*/$.#?6#$*#.) 0/%),2#)5&@/%1,()/0 ,2#)*/556$1,(:) ! .,#5.)0%/5),2#)6,1'1,&%1&$).,%#&5)/0)5/%&')+21'/./+2(

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Contract-Based Approach

! +.5$&#0$67#8,9(:33&.#0; ! "(&"%(*-/'.*0(2&.$,.(*.#($)*&70*(.#$+,%*)/%('*,03*")$0+$"%('*4&)* .#(-'(%1(' ! 0&.$&0*&4*.#( :)$2$0,%*;&'$.$&08*,*#6"&.#(.$+,%*'$./,.$&0*$0*7#$+#* (1()6&0(*0(2&.$,.('*4)&-*5(#$03*,*<($%*&4*=20&),0+(9

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Business Ethics Defined

! C4,+2*,,'*()+.,' ! &)*/$.*1/6.$#..)/0)32&,)1.)%1"2,)/%)3%/$")1$),2#)3/%A+'&*#) &$-)&)*/551,5#$,),/),&A1$")%#.+/$.171'1,()0/%)&$)#,21*&') */6%.#)/0)&*,1/$)1$)76.1$#..)/+#%&,1/$.:

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Stakeholders

! E(#5*)%61*&' ! #B+&$.14#),#%5),2&,)1$*'6-#.)&)76.1$#..)#$,1,(9.)/3$#%.8) 1$4#.,/%.8)#5+'/(##.8)*6.,/5#%.8).6++'1#%.8)&$-),2#)31-#%) */556$1,(: ! C%15&%(8).#*/$-&%(

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Stakeholders

! <&/2#&=(8$#>,;.'9,&8( ! 2(0(),%%6 .#&'(*7#&*7$%%*4((%*,*3$)(+.*$-",+.*5,'(3*&0*.#(* 3(+$'$&0

! ?,0.59#&=(8$#>,;.'9,&8( ! .#&'(*7#&*3&*0&.*#,1(*,06*3$)(+.*+&00(+.$&0*.&*.#( 5/'$0(''*5/.*-,6*'/44()*'&-(*,31()'(*+&0'(>/(0+('*$0*,0* $03$)(+.*7,69*

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Moral Minimum versus Maximizing Profits

! "#$%&'()*)(+(',-.#$/' ! "#$%&'()"*+(+,&*-#"**+.%+/0%+#%+1('23+%'4+(5."'#(.-6"574+/0%+.1"+5"(*.+ 8%**-,5"+1('293+:*+5%#)+(* .1"+,&*-#"**+'"2(-#*+8'%;-.(,5"4 .1"+$%28(#7+*.'-6"*+.%+($.+(*+".1-$(557+(*+8%**-,5"4+"6"#+(.+.1"+ "<8"#*"+%;+*%2"+(00-.-%#(5 8'%;-.*9

! 0'1#(2%*/',-%,'3#&&#45'%'(%6)()7)*8'2$#3),5',-.#$/'5,$)9.5',#' (%:.'%5'(+1-'(#*./'%5'2#55);&.<'%5'&#*8'%5 *#'&%45'%$.' ;$#:.*

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Values Management

! ?#64*,'"#2#7*9*2( ! #5+2&.1<#.)+%1/%1,1<1$")5/%&')4&'6#.)0/%),2#)/%"&$1<&,1/$) &$-)#$.6%1$"),2&,)7#2&41/%.)&%#)&'1"$#-)31,2),2/.#)4&'6#.:)

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Common Traits of Effective Values Management

! "#2#7*9*2('#&(+.46#(*,'#'.6*#&'8+,+%2'%-'*()+.,'#21' +2(*7&+(<'()&%47)'#66'6*8*6,'%-'()*'%&7#2+F#(+%2/

! "#2#7*9*2(G,'8+,+%2'%-'*()+.,'#21'+2(*7&+(<'+,' +2(*7&#(*1'+2(%'#66'6*8*6,'%-'()*'1*.+,+%2B9#5+27' ;&%.*,,'%-'()*'%&7#2+F#(+%2/

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Advantages of Values Management D6',14&,1/$)/0)E,%/$")F#&53/%A)&$-) C%/-6*,141,(

D'&%1,()1$)G6.1$#..)H+#%&,1/$.

C67'1*)I5&"#

E,&(1$"),2#);,21*&')D/6%.#)1$)F6%76'#$,) F15#. !"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66*

%&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

AIG Example ! DHI'J#,'+2'()*'.*2(*&'%-'()*'-+2#2.+#6'.&+,+,'%-'KLLM' ()#('.469+2#(*1'+2'9#,,+8*'7%8*&29*2('3#+6%4(,'-%&' -+2#2.+#6'+2,(+(4(+%2,'#21'%()*&,'J)%'J*&*'.%2,+1*&*1' (%%'+9;%&(#2('(%'()*'-+2#2.+#6'+2-&#,(&4.(4&*'(%'3*' #66%J*1'(%'-#+6/'

! N4,('9%2(),'3*-%&*'()*'3%24,*,'J*&*'1+,(&+34(*1O'DHI' )#1'&*.*+8*1'PQRS'3+66+%2'+2'(#T;#<*&'9%2*<'+2' *T.)#27*'-%&'#2'ML';*&.*2(',(#5*'+2'DHI'-%&'()*'U/E/' 7%8*&29*2(/ !"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66*

%&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

! @%&;%&#(*',%.+#6'&*,;%2,+3+6+(<'V@E>W' ! 1$4/'4#.)&)7%/&-#%J7&.#-)1-#$,101*&,1/$)/0)15+/%,&$,) 76.1$#..)&$-)./*1&')1..6#.)&$-)&)*%1,1?6#)/0)76.1$#..) /%"&$1<&,1/$.)&$-)+%&*,1*#.: ! ,2#)$&%%/3)41#38),2#)5/-#%&,#)41#38)&$-),2#)7%/&-)41#3:

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

The Narrow View: Greed Is Good

! =.%2%9+,('"+6(%2':&+*19#2';&%;%,*1'()#('()*'%26<' &*,;%2,+3+6+(<'#'34,+2*,,')#,'+,'(%'9#T+9+F*' ,)#&*)%61*&'J*#6() ! "#2#7*&,'J)%';4&,4*',%.+#6'+2+(+#(+8*,'J+()'.%&;%&#(*' -421,'#&*'8+%6#(+27'()*+&'-+14.+#&<'14(+*,'(%'()*'%J2*&,' %-'()*'.%&;%&#(+%2/'

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

The Moderate View: Just Follow the Law

! H('+,'()*'7%8*&29*2(G,'$%3'(%'*,(#36+,)'6*7#6'#21 &*746#(%&<'74+1*6+2*,'-%&'34,+2*,,'3*.#4,*'()*' 7%8*&29*2('#6&*#1<'&*;&*,*2(,'()*'#77&*7#(*'9%&#6' 8+*J,'%-'()*';436+./

! U21*&'()+,'8+*JO'#'34,+2*,,G,'*()+.#6'&*,;%2,+3+6+(<'+,'(% .%9;6<'J+()'()*'6#J'#21';4&,4*'%3$*.(+8*,'()#('#&*' 6*7#6/' !"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66*

%&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":

The Broad View: Good Corporate Citizenship

! 0)*'3&%#1'8+*J'%-'@E>'#6,%'+28%68*,'()*'2%(+%2 %-'X.%&;%&#(*'.+(+F*2,)+;OY'J)+.)'9*#2,'#'34,+2*,,' ,)%461',(&+8*'(%';&%9%(*'()*'*.%2%9+.O'6*7#6O'*()+.#6O' #21';)+6#2()&%;+.',%.+#6'&*,;%2,+3+6+(+*,'*T;*.(*1'%-'+(' 3<'+(,',(#5*)%61*&,/

!"#$%&'()*+*,-,.*/01%2345&66*78902)&":;*<66* %&'()=*%>=>%?>8;*@"*%>#%"890)&":*"%*8&=)%&A9)&":* 3&)("9)*)(>*#%&"%*3%&))>:*0":=>:)*"B*/01%234

5&66*78902)&":