Order id #1513078164Task Topic Journal Article Review 5

BUSI 613 Journal Article Review Grading Rubric

Criteria

Levels of Achievement

Content 70%

Advanced

Proficient

Developing

Not present

Scholarly Research

and

Length

1

6

to

17

points

Obvious and intensive scholarly

research with 900 words

in total

submitted

1

4

to

1

5

points

Sufficient scholarly research with

between 550 and 899 words

submitted

1

to

1

3

points

Some scholarly research but not

obvious and less than 550 words

submitted

0 points

Author

’

s Purpose

1

2

to

1

3

points

Author’s p

urpose is clear and

detailed

with 100 words submitted

1

1

points

Author’s p

urpose is

stated

but lacks

sufficient explanation

with 50 to 99

words submitted

1

to

1

0

points

Author’s p

urpose is short with

missing

details

and

less than 50 words

submitted

0 points

Background of the

Issue

1

2

to

1

3

points

Background

of the issue

is

discussed in strong detail

with 175

words submitted

1

1

points

Background

of the issue

is

discussed in

sufficient detail

with

100

-

174 words submitted

1

to

1

0

points

Discussion of background

of the issue

is

short, weak, or unclear

with less

than 100 words submitted

0 points

Application of Supply

Chain Management

(SCM) Theory

12 to 13 points

Strong

application of SCM theory

with 175 words submitted

11 points

Sufficient application of SCM theory

with 100

-

174 words submitted

1 to 10 points

Weak application of SCM theory with

less than 100 words submitted

Managerial

Implications

18

to

20

points

350 or more words

of direct

advice to managers offered

17

points

200

to

350 words

of direct advice to

managers offered

1

to

1

6

points

Less than 200 words

of direct advice

to managers offered

0 points

Summary

1

1

to

1

2

points

100

or more

words

that concisely

summarize article

submitted

1

0

points

Summary addresses article content

in

50

to 100 words

1

to

9

points

Summary is

less than

50 words

and

fails to capture significant aspects of

article content

0 points

Structure 30%

Advanced

Proficient

Developing

Not present

Title Page, Immediate

Article Identification,

References page

18

to

20

points

Title and references pages

complete and properly formatted,

article reviewed is immediately

identified

17

points

Title and

references pages mostly

complete and properly formatted,

article reviewed i

s

immediately

identified

1

to

1

6

points

One of these pages is missing, or both

are incomplete or incorrectly

formatted,

or

article reviewed is not

immediately identified

0

points

APA Formatting

10

points

Few

to no APA errors present

8

to

9

points

Relatively small number of APA

errors present

1

to

7

points

Significant number of APA errors

present

0 points

Grammar and

Spelling

7

points

Few

to no spelling/grammatical

errors present

6

points

Relatively small number of

spelling/grammar errors present

1

to

5

points

Significant number of

spelling/grammatical errors present

0 points

BUSI 613 Journal Article Review Grading Rubric

Criteria Levels of Achievement

Content 70% Advanced Proficient Developing Not present

Scholarly Research

and Length

16 to 17 points

Obvious and intensive scholarly

research with 900 words in total

submitted

14 to 15 points

Sufficient scholarly research with

between 550 and 899 words

submitted

1 to 13 points

Some scholarly research but not

obvious and less than 550 words

submitted

0 points

Author’s Purpose

12 to 13 points

Author’s purpose is clear and

detailed with 100 words submitted

11 points

Author’s purpose is stated but lacks

sufficient explanation with 50 to 99

words submitted

1 to 10 points

Author’s purpose is short with missing

details and less than 50 words

submitted

0 points

Background of the

Issue

12 to 13 points

Background of the issue is

discussed in strong detail with 175

words submitted

11 points

Background of the issue is

discussed in sufficient detail with

100-174 words submitted

1 to 10 points

Discussion of background of the issue

is short, weak, or unclear with less

than 100 words submitted

0 points

Application of Supply

Chain Management

(SCM) Theory

12 to 13 points

Strong application of SCM theory

with 175 words submitted

11 points

Sufficient application of SCM theory

with 100-174 words submitted

1 to 10 points

Weak application of SCM theory with

less than 100 words submitted

Managerial

Implications

18 to 20 points

350 or more words of direct

advice to managers offered

17 points

200 to 350 words of direct advice to

managers offered

1 to 16 points

Less than 200 words of direct advice

to managers offered

0 points

Summary

11 to 12 points

100 or more words that concisely

summarize article submitted

10 points

Summary addresses article content

in 50 to 100 words

1 to 9 points

Summary is less than 50 words and

fails to capture significant aspects of

article content

0 points

Structure 30% Advanced Proficient Developing Not present

Title Page, Immediate

Article Identification,

References page

18 to 20 points

Title and references pages

complete and properly formatted,

article reviewed is immediately

identified

17 points

Title and references pages mostly

complete and properly formatted,

article reviewed is immediately

identified

1 to 16 points

One of these pages is missing, or both

are incomplete or incorrectly

formatted, or article reviewed is not

immediately identified

0 points

APA Formatting

10 points

Few to no APA errors present

8 to 9 points

Relatively small number of APA

errors present

1 to 7 points

Significant number of APA errors

present

0 points

Grammar and

Spelling

7 points

Few to no spelling/grammatical

errors present

6 points

Relatively small number of

spelling/grammar errors present

1 to 5 points

Significant number of

spelling/grammatical errors present

0 points