PICOT question

sagale
ArticleAppraisalAssignmentRubric.docx

Article Appraisal Assignment Rubric

Article Appraisal Assignment Rubric

Criteria

Ratings

Pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeContent

30 pts

Excellent

The assignment thoroughly addresses the question(s) or topic. Content is exceptionally well-presented and argued; ideas are detailed, well-developed, and supported with specific evidence, facts, and examples.

24 pts

Good

The assignment adequately addresses the question(s) or topic. Content is well-presented and argued; ideas are detailed, developed and supported with general evidence, facts and details.

21 pts

Satisfactory

The post minimally addresses the question(s) or topic. Content is presented, but ideas are not well developed or supported. Some evidence or facts are presented, but are more general or less specific.

0 pts

Unsatisfactory

The assignment does not addresses the question(s) or topic. Ideas are not clearly presented and not supported with evidence or facts.

30 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeOrganization

30 pts

Excellent

Writing is well-organized and easy for a reader to follow.

24 pts

Good

Writing reflects some organization but is not easily followed by a reader.

21 pts

Satisfactory

Writing is not effectively organized and is difficult for a reader to follow.

0 pts

Unsatisfactory

Writing is disorganized and is difficult for a reader to follow.

30 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeSources - APA, references, and citations

15 pts

Excellent

Scholarly sources are current and exceptionally well-integrated and support opinions argued in the assignment very effectively. Citations follow APA guidelines - no errors. The minimum number of sources are used, following the assignment instructions.

12 pts

Good

Scholarly sources are current and well integrated and effectively support the opinions argued in the assignment. One to three APA errors, but the citation follow APA guidelines. Minimum number of sources are used, following the assignment instructions.

10.5 pts

Satisfactory

Sources support some opinions made in the assignment, but might not be integrated well within the argument. Not all sources are scholarly. Use APA format with four to six errors. Minimum number of sources are used, following the assignment instructions.

0 pts

Unsatisfactory

The assignment does not use scholarly sources or if it does, the sources are not integrated well. The sources are not cited correctly according to APA guidelines. The minimum number of sources are not used, according to the assignment instructions.

15 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeMechanics: grammar, punctuation and style

15 pts

Excellent

Writing reflects no grammatical, punctuation or style errors.

12 pts

Good

Writing reflects 1-3 grammatical, punctuation or style errors.

10.5 pts

Satisfactory

Writing reflects 4-6 grammatical, punctuation or style errors.

0 pts

Unsatisfactory

Writing reflects more than 6 grammatical punctuation or style errors.

15 pts

Total Points: 90

Previous Next