Adressing an ethical issue

CRITERIA 

NON-PERFORMANCE 

BASIC 

PROFICIENT 

DISTINGUISHED 

Evaluate the parameters of ethical decision-making models as they apply to a recommended policy.

Does not identify the parameters of ethical decision-making models as they apply to a recommended policy. 

Identifies, but does not evaluate, the parameters of ethical decision-making models as they apply to a recommended policy. 

Evaluates the parameters of ethical decision-making models as they apply to a recommended policy. 

Evaluates the parameters of ethical decision-making models as they apply to a recommended policy, and explains how the decision-making model selected justifies the recommended corporate policy. 

Assess how the recommended corporate policy is socially responsible.

Does not identify how the recommended corporate policy is socially responsible. 

Identifies, but does not assess, how the recommended corporate policy is socially responsible. 

Assesses how the recommended corporate policy is socially responsible. 

Assesses how the recommended corporate policy is socially responsible, and justifies the responsibility. 

Recommend a corporate policy for resolving an ethical issue.

Does not outline a corporate policy for resolving an issue. 

Outlines a corporate policy for resolving an issue. 

Recommends a corporate policy for resolving an issue. 

Recommends a corporate policy for resolving an issue, and provides examples of how the comprehensive nature of the corporate policy covers the major aspects of the issue. 

Support a corporate policy recommendation for business ethics policies and standards with well-reasoned analysis and specific examples.

Does not support a corporate policy recommendation for business ethics policies and standards. 

Supports a corporate policy recommendation for business ethics policies and standards but does not have well-reasoned analysis and specific examples. 

Supports a corporate policy recommendation for business ethics policies and standards with well-reasoned analysis and specific examples. 

Supports a corporate policy recommendation for business ethics policies and standards with well-reasoned analysis and specific examples, and cites statistics based on cited resources that also support the recommendation. 

Recommend a strategy for communicating a policy to the organization in a manner that meets the needs of an audience.

Does not outline a strategy for communicating a policy to an organization. 

Outlines a strategy for communicating a policy to the organization in a manner that does not meet the needs of an audience. 

Recommends a strategy for communicating a policy to the organization in a manner that meets the needs of an audience. 

Recommends a strategy for communicating a policy to the organization in a manner that meets the needs of an audience, and explains and justifies how the communication meets those needs. 

Describe potential limitations of a recommended policy, and strategies for monitoring and compliance.

Does not describe potential limitations of a recommended policy or strategies for monitoring and compliance. 

Describes potential limitations of a recommended policy, or describes strategies for monitoring and compliance. 

Describes potential limitations of a recommended policy, and strategies for monitoring and compliance. 

Describes potential limitations of a recommended policy, and strategies for monitoring and compliance, and explains the repercussions of not complying to that corporate policy.