business idea
IRE347 TRAINING & DEVELOPMENT Anny Fong M.Eng, MBA, LL.M, PMP
July 27, 2022
Agenda
¨ Common questions from exit cards ¨ Recap from previous class ¨ Transfer of Training ¨ Case Discussion ¨ A look into the (near) future ¨ Group work
2
© Anny Fong
Common questions from exit cards
TBD 3
© Anny Fong
Quick recap of previous class
¨ Lesson plans ¨ Qualities of an effective trainer ¨ Logistics ¨ Scheduling ¨ Administration ¨ Ethics ¨ Learning climate ¨ Gagné’s 9 Events of instruction ¨ Closing training ¨ Common problems and possible solutions
© Anny Fong
4
First impressions of Transfer of Training
¨ Kahoot!
¨ To participate, join at ¤ www.kahoot.it or Kahoot! App ¤ Enter the game PIN when it’s time
5
© Anny Fong
What do we mean by ”transfer of training”? 6
© Anny Fong
¨ Generalization of knowledge and skills learned in training
¨ Maintenance of required of acquired knowledge and skills over time
Image source: PBWorks
Here’s the problem though 7
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
What does the research say? 8
© Anny Fong
¨ Hughes et al. conducted a meta- analysis on the efficacy of training transfer
¨ Work environment support variables (peer, supervisor, organizational support) ¤ Moderate and positive correlations
with transfer of training ¤ Motivation to transfer mediates the
work environment support variables and transfer
¤ Positively related to sustainment n Peer and supervisor support showed
strongest relationships
(SOURCE: The Role of Work Environment in Training Sustainment: A Meta-Analysis Ashley M. Hughes, The University of Illinois at Chicago, USA, Stephanie Zajac, MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, USA, Amanda L. Woods,nand Eduardo Salas, Rice University, Houston, Texas, USA Human Factors, DOI: 10.1177/0018720819845988)
Did you know?
The #1 barrier to transfer of training is the immediate manager’s lack of support for training
Transfer of Training Process 9
Copyright © 2019 by Nelson Education Ltd.
Training Inputs – Trainee Characteristics 10
© Anny Fong
Cognitive abilities
Motivational factors
Personality traits
Values
Goal orientation
Job attitudes
etc.
Most strongly related to transfer
Training Inputs – Training Design 11
© Anny Fong
Identical elements
• Experiences and conditions during training that closely resemble the actual work environment
General principles
• General rules and theory that underlie the application
Stimulus variability
• Multiple examples
• Practices experiences in a variety of situations
Training Inputs – Training Environment 12
© Anny Fong
Pre/post- training
environment
Messaging to
employees
Opportunity to perform
Continuous learning culture
Image sources: The Noun Project: time machine by Beckstein, stage by Bernd Lakenbrink, message by AliWijaya, continuous playing by artworkbean
Transfer of Training Strategies – Before 13
© Anny Fong
M a
na g
e m
e nt •Assess who should attend
(readiness to learn, trainability, perceived value to EE)
•Messaging •EE involvement •Be ready to
provide support
Tr a
in e
r •Application of ISD model
•Preparing stakeholders
•Clarifying expectations
•Ensuring management/ EE communication
•Ensuring trainees are prepared
Tr a
in e
e s •Find out about
programs prior to attendance
•Discuss action plans with manager
•Prepare for program including completing any pre-work needed
Image sources: The Noun Project: boss by Hans trainman, Teacher by Federico Galaschi, students by Timo Schmid
Transfer of Training Strategies – During 14
© Anny Fong
M a
na g
e m
e nt •Attend and participate before
trainees •Reassign EE’s work
so that EE can attend
•Remove interruptions during training
Tr a
in e
r •Incorporate learning practices to engage
•Apply learning principles (e.g. identical elements)
•Include relevant content and examples
•Have trainees prepare and commit to a performance contract for the transfer of trained skills on the job
Tr a
in e
e s •Attend with a
growth mindset •Actively engage •Develop action
plan for application of training on the job
Image sources: The Noun Project: boss by Hans trainman, Teacher by Federico Galaschi, students by Timo Schmid
Transfer of Training Strategies – After 15
© Anny Fong
M a
na g
e m
e nt •Ensure EE has immediate and
frequent opportunities to practice
•Encourage and reinforce application of new skills on the job
•Provide recognition and positive feedback for the use of new skills
•Evaluate EE’s use of trained skills on the job
Tr a
in e
r •Stay involved in the training and transfer process
•Conduct field visits •Provide feedback •Conduct follow-up
sessions Tr a
in e
e s •Use new
knowledge and skills on the job as frequently as possible
•Discuss with manager opportunities for transfer
•Form a “buddy system” with peers who attended the training
Image sources: The Noun Project: boss by Hans trainman, Teacher by Federico Galaschi, students by Timo Schmid
Transfer of Training Interventions 16
© Anny Fong
¨ Provided at the end of a training program to facilitate the transfer of training
Relapse prevention
Self- managementGoal-setting
Relapse Prevention 17
© Anny Fong
What is relapse?
• When a trainee reverts to using old skills or to pre-training behaviours
What can we do to prevent it?
• Instruct trainees to anticipate transfer obstacles and high-risk situations
• Develop skills and strategies to overcome obstacles
• Develop coping strategies for high-risk situations
Self-Management 18
© Anny Fong
¨ Teach trainees to perform steps to manage their transfer behaviour
Anticipate obstacles
Plan to overcome
them Set goals Monitor progress
Reward for goal
attainment
Image sources: The Noun Project: Roadblock by Cuputo, plan by Sumit Saengthong, goal by Larea, trends by Setyo Ari Wibowo, Trophy by Vectorstall
Goal-Setting 19
© Anny Fong
¨ Teaches trainees about the goal-setting process and how to set specific goals for using trained skills on the job
pecific
easurable
chievable
esults-Based
ime-Sensitive
Post-Training Supplements 20
© Anny Fong
¨ Interventions that take place on the job following a training program
Booster sessions
• Extensions of training
• Debriefs about transfer experiences and obstacles
Self-coaching
• Reflecting on own performance
• Setting transfer goals upon completion
Upward feedback
• Provide data on frequency of post-training behaviours
• Trainees can establish improvement goals
“The School Board” case
Breakout Discussion 1. What are some of the reasons that the training did not
transfer well? 2. What are some of the transfer strategies that could
have been implemented before training, during training, and after training?
3. What are some of the transfer of training interventions that can be leveraged? Consider booster sessions, self- coaching, and upward feedback.
4. What could be some practical challenges of implementing the training interventions?
5. What could be some unintended consequences of this training?
© Anny Fong
21
Summary 22
© Anny Fong
¨ Transfer of training – what is it? ¨ Transfer of training process ¨ Training inputs that impact the transfer of
training ¤ Trainee characteristics ¤ Training design ¤ Work environment
¨ Transfer of training strategies ¤ Before/during/after
¨ Transfer of training interventions ¨ Post-training supplements
Exit cards! 23
© Anny Fong
¨ Before you leave today, please fill in the exit card ¤ Instead of an ‘attendance’ sign in ¤ Opportunity to reflect on today’s class
¨ Quercus > Quizzes > Exit Card – Class 8
Note about next week’s class 24
© Anny Fong
¨ Focus is on project check-ins during class ¨ No “regular lecture” ¨ Each group should book a time with me
¤ Book before July 29 ¤ Link to Google doc to book
(also on Quercus > Class 9) ¤ Only attend the time slot booked for your
group
Looking Forward
© Anny Fong
Aug 3 •Project
check-ins
Aug 8 •Evaluating
training
Aug 10 •Training
programs
Aug 15 •Review
25
Image sources: The Noun Project: Crystal ball by Sumit Saengthong, waving hello by Zach Bogart, evaluation by Dinosoft Lab, collection by Markus, books by Jakub Čaja