About Present Logitech

CATEGORY

Not acceptable

Satisfactory Performance

Outstanding Performance            

Financial

Viability

15%

Not quantified well

or numbers weren’t

explained well

11 and less

Analysis fairly clear, but

Lacks important analysis

nor conclusions.

12-16

Analysis very clear,  as well as

conclusions.

17-19

Vision,  goals

and planning

15%

Critique  not specific

nor able to interpret

direction of Logitech.

11 and less

Analysis relatively clear,

but few examples.

12-16

Analysis of factors that stimulate (and repress) innovation: 10%

One or two factors identified and/or not explained well for stimulating and repressing innovation.

8 or less

3 factors identified and explained relatively well for stimulating and repressing innovation.

9-10

At least 5 factors identified and explained well for each stimulating and repressing innovation.

11-12

Executive leadership

10%

Not specific on whether

Leadership is linked to

Good choices of organizational action.

8 or less.

discussion on match of executive leadership to appropriate change is

not specific, less than 2 examples.  9-10

Excellent discussion on match of executive leadership to appropriate change, at least 3 good examples.

11-12

Use of global context:10%

 Analysis was very brief and not well described (one significant point).

8 or less

Analysis was reasonably well described and had at least two significant points with examples.

9-10

 Current use of global context very well done, with at least three significant points with examples.  

11-12

Overall summary:

SWOT:

15%

Analysis relatively clear but

SWOT explained briefly (15 entries) and/or with some errors.  

12-16

Analysis clear and concise of SWOT to explain with several examples with high quality 16+ entries

Correlated to the analysis above.   

17-20

Suggestions for future:15%

Almost no creative ideas for future modifications in organization to assure innovation; little or no projecting future issues with supporting logic.

11 and less

Some creative ideas for future modifications in organization to assure innovation; little or no projecting future issues with supporting logic.

12-16

Creative ideas for managing innovation in the future as well as identifying logical issues that may emerge.

17-19

Use of resources:

10%

Thorough analysis in examining organization and competitors. Reputable, current info. References (less than 15) cited with some errors per guidelines. 8 or less

Reasonable analysis in examining org. & competitors. Reputable, current refs. (15-19) cited per guidelines. Minor errors.

9-10

Detailed analysis in examining org. & competitors. Reputable, current refs. (20+) cited per guidelines

11-12